Cultural Exchange v Appropriation

Is Asian Rap Cultural Appropriation?” – Broadly, 2019, 13:22 -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RvqCEVun2y0

Is it still cultural appropriation when it is done by minority groups? This video features sociologist Ninochka McTaggart and unpacks the nuances surrounding the debate. Loosely defined, cultural appropriation occurs when the dominant group disrespectfully adopts elements from other cultures, and this is often done for personal profit (monetary gain, looking cool/fashionable, etc.). Furthermore, there is no consideration for the original meaning of the cultural element, and the original culture does not benefit from the appropriation. Cultural exchange, on the other hand, is non-exploitative and should ideally empower both cultures. How else might we delineate the two? What other examples of cultural appropriation can you think of? How about examples of non-appropriated cultural exchange?

From the video’s description: With a large number of Asian artists breaking into the hip hop scene, the conversation surrounding cultural appropriation has become more common. Model Salem Mitchell sits down with local LA rapper, Hollei Day to discuss Asians in Hip Hop, and the female rapper’s views on cultural appropriation. We explore the fine line between cultural appropriation and cultural exchange.